← Back to Notes

Graeme Macrae Burnet

Benbecula

Years after his brother killed his parents and aunt, a man living alone recounts what led to the murders.

Novel · 141 pages · Kindle Edition · 2025 · Polygon

A brain in a house of bone

On Benbecula in 1857, Angus MacPhee murders his parents and aunt. His brother Malcolm tells us how it happened.

Years after the murders, Malcolm lives alone on the island. In Graeme Macrae Burnet’s Benbecula, he looks back on the family’s poverty and his neighbours’ shortcomings with the assurance of a man who expects to be believed. He explains almost everything. Even actions that cast him in a less favourable light get an explanation. His account supplies evidence against the judgements he makes.

Malcolm is entertaining company. He considers himself an intelligent man surrounded by fools. His pedantry can be very funny. A trivial disagreement may provoke pages of reasoning. He interferes in other people’s affairs, treating their objections as proof of their stupidity. Deception poses little difficulty for him. He can admit to it without grasping what the admission reveals.

Burnet rarely needs to interrupt him. The reader hears the defence and recognises the conduct it attempts to excuse.

Malcolm repeatedly dismisses his brother John as incapable of independent thought. John has proposed leaving Benbecula and persuaded their sister Marion to accompany him. He says he wants to escape Malcolm. The man Malcolm regards as a fool has identified the source of the household’s misery with greater accuracy than its self-appointed authority. Malcolm answers with sarcastic applause, and when John compares him to Angus he takes hold of John’s jacket and raises his fist. He claims to have held back. In his telling, striking John would have proved the accusation. Marion intervenes before he releases John.

The family’s hardship is real. Collecting seaware is exhausting, and the returns are miserable. Marion pays with injured hands. Her savings for passage to Portree are her answer. She and John offer Malcolm a place. He rejects it and declares that Marion will not leave either.

Malcolm has good reason to resent his circumstances. He has no comparable claim over Marion’s future. Her work, to him, is family duty. Her departure is an offence. The way out comes through Marion, whom he has treated as indispensable to his own comfort. His attempt to stop her makes his grievance harder to accept on its own terms. Years earlier he drove off her suitor, Callum MacDade, with an invented story of Marion dancing undressed round a fire on the moor. Malcolm calls it protection. John and Marion act independently. Malcolm still controls how their decisions reach the reader.

Burnet builds Malcolm’s lopsided attention into the novel’s form. Plain sentences run into long paragraphs of qualification and digression, and dialogue often proceeds through repeated speech tags with little typographical interruption. The reading is easy. The proportions are less straightforward. A minor grievance receives elaborate treatment, and the departure of John and Marion passes in a few lines.

Malcolm passes over the middle hours of the day. They were uneventful, he says. Angus murders their family during those hours. Malcolm knows this as he tells it. He leaves the killings to Angus, whose confession he later reports almost without interruption. Malcolm’s absurd calculations sit beside bodily violence without a change to a grander register. The comedy survives.

Mrs MacLeod, a neighbour’s wife, comes each week to tidy his house. Malcolm admits that he regularly thinks of forcing himself on her. Restraint, he argues, separates him from Angus. He concludes that her visits exist to give him the chance to exercise it.

Malcolm calls his house the skullhouse and likens himself to the brain within it. He assigns the windows and door their anatomical equivalents. The conceit is funny in its elaboration. It suits a man who watches his neighbours and considers himself qualified to judge them. Yet the brain is enclosed. The openings through which Malcolm surveys the world define the limits of his position.

The house acquires a different character when Malcolm begins to doubt whether Mrs MacLeod comes at all. He names an adversarial voice in his head Angus. The observer who once surveyed the world from his windows struggles to establish what he has seen.

Late in the novel Malcolm warns that a man can only restrain himself for so long. Press hard enough on the handle of a tool, he says, and it snaps. When a group of men approaches the house, Malcolm hides beneath the bed. As they break down the door, his dead mother lies beside him and turns into Marion. He tells her he would lie with her a little. Angus used almost the same words to the aunt he killed. The warning announces the scene. Elsewhere Burnet leaves Malcolm’s perceptions in doubt, but the restraint he boasted of runs straight to Angus’s line.

The men drag him out. Before they came, Malcolm could no longer reach the window. Now he questions whether he has ever lived in the skullhouse, and whether he is in a cell or a box. The afterword records Angus’s forty-two years of incarceration. It leaves Malcolm’s circumstances unresolved.

Burnet has allowed Malcolm to judge his family and defend his conduct at length, and his own testimony repeatedly casts doubt on those judgements. The skullhouse turns that doubt on the place from which he speaks. Malcolm is still reasoning at the end. He is unsure where he is.