← Back to Notes

Douglas Stuart

John of John

A son taught to weave until his work matches his father's, inheriting a life he never agreed to.

464 pages · Kindle edition · Grove Atlantic, 2026

Two hands made indistinguishable

On his way home to Harris, Cal crouches in a bus shelter and repacks his bag. He hides a gay newspaper beneath the lining and covers it with dirty laundry. His mother’s discarded Bible goes on top. Before he has reached his father’s house, he has begun arranging himself for inspection.

The island asks for another arrangement. On the ferry a woman asks Cal who he belongs to, and his answer supplies the novel’s title: John of John of Iain of Iain the weaver. Identity is lineage here. Cal comes home carrying four years of mainland life, yet Harris still locates him through his father and the men before him. The question running through the novel is how much of that inheritance can be carried without reproducing it.

Douglas Stuart sets John of John on the Isle of Harris in the Outer Hebrides. Devotion and labour both turn on that problem of resemblance. Cal's father, John Macleod, is a deacon and a weaver. His authority rests on religious certainty and endurance. Cal has returned from art school. He brings different habits and knowledge of a larger life. Yet father and son remain closest in forms of work they share.

At the loom the inheritance is physical. John teaches Cal until Cal's beating matches his father's closely enough that the finished cloth conceals the work of two men. Cal succeeds by making his hand indistinguishable from his father's. Almost immediately Cal is afraid. He could stay at that loom until he is older than John. Skill offers a place within the family economy and a possible future he does not want. Inheritance is practical before it is moral. A rhythm learnt at the loom can reproduce a life long before anyone agrees to it.

Language carries a similar division. John often speaks Gaelic with Cal in ways that exclude Ella, Cal's grandmother who helped raise him. The language of family and place is a private claim between father and son. Between John and Innes, the man John has loved in secret for decades, Gaelic can shelter intimacy from the surrounding community. English enters when concealment can no longer do the work required of it. Innes changes language when he needs John to hear what their hidden life has cost him. He speaks plainly. The novel's silences contain plenty of speech. What changes is who may hear it and how much truth each form can bear.

In Stuart's Harris, desire turns into conduct. A glance is checked and a hand withdrawn. A conversation is redirected, an object hidden before somebody sees it. John can strike his son yet later sit at the table and rub ointment carefully into hands damaged by the loom. Affection survives without declaration. That makes the violence harder rather than easier to absorb. The same domestic system can carry tenderness, discipline, work and harm without separating them cleanly.

Cal eventually discovers that his father's concealment is not an older version of a problem he alone has escaped. It is a possible version of his own future. John and Innes have spent decades converting love into routine and stolen access to one another. That arrangement finally fails. Recognition comes late, but it comes. John admits that he would follow Innes if he knew where to find him, and Cal understands what had been hidden inside their family history.

The closing movement is less controlled. The novel builds through repetition and slow disclosure. Then deaths and decisions follow one another quickly, and the final stretch leans on plot pressure the earlier chapters rarely need.

John of John permits departures and partial admissions. None restores the years surrendered. Staying carries cost. Leaving carries another. Those costs stay material. They sit in a bag repacked for home and in two hands made indistinguishable at a loom.

Disclosure: Advance copy provided by NetGalley and Grove Atlantic.

Part of Reading Masculinity.

Reading Queer Life | Legibility and Experience
Queer life in literature, tracing gay identity.