Yes, Daddy
A young waiter drawn into a playwright’s Hamptons compound, the abuse replayed louder until thriller takes over.
293 pages · Kindle edition · May 2021
A serious book with serious intentions. That does not make it a strong one
Jonah Keller has fled Illinois, where his preacher father forced him into conversion therapy. In New York he waits tables and hopes to write. He meets Richard Shriver, a Pulitzer-winning playwright, who invites him to a compound in the Hamptons for the summer. The summer turns into abuse.
Mace Miller, a former child star, is abused there too. When Mace takes Richard to court, Jonah testifies for Richard and says none of it happened. The novel is Jonah’s address to Mace, written years later. Mace answers once.
The good
Jonathan Parks-Ramage steadies Yes, Daddy when it finally slows down. The closing chapters with Jonah’s father show restraint and proportion. They avoid performance and settle for presence. Mace’s letter brings the clearest moral line in the book. Forgiveness is optional. Trauma explains behaviour but does not erase responsibility. These sections trust silence and scale, and they work.
The bad
For much of its length, the book relies on repetition rather than insight. Abuse and power imbalance are identified early, inside a relationship shaped by wealth, age and status within contemporary queer life, then replayed at higher volume without being pushed further. Once the Hamptons storyline slips into thriller mode, interior life thins out. Momentum replaces thought. The media backlash reads as familiar terrain, registered rather than examined.
The ugly
The conversion-to-Jesus arc is the novel’s weakest turn. It swaps one system of control for another, then rushes past its own implications. Sexual harm inside the church becomes another escalation beat, not a reckoning. Jonah’s complicity is acknowledged, then repeatedly softened by circumstance. Accountability arrives late and without much force.
Verdict
Yes, Daddy engages urgent material and occasionally handles it well. For long stretches, it confuses intensity with precision and insists on significance it has not earned. I finished it aware of what it wanted to say, unconvinced by how it said it, and largely unmoved.
